Skip to content

What I’m a Celebrity.. can teach us about surveillance, privacy and cyber security – UoG expert

As millions of viewers tune in to watch famous people tackle jungle challenges on I’m a Celebrity… Get Me Out of Here!, a University of Gloucestershire cyber security expert says the reality show offers an important lesson in surveillance, privacy and the power of data.

Dr Will Sayers, cyber security expert at the University, believes the long-running programme highlights how people behave differently when they know they are being watched, and that whoever controls the information controls the story that is ultimately told.

While contestants willingly step into the spotlight on the TV show, Dr Sayers says similar questions arise every day through workplace monitoring tools, smartphone apps, facial recognition technology and other systems that collect information about people’s behaviour.

Dr Sayers said: “Put most of us in the jungle with cameras rolling and a plate of insects in front of us, and we’d almost certainly act differently than we would at home if faced with the same scenario. The contestants on I’m a Celebrity know they’re being watched, and that inevitably changes how they behave.

“That same principle applies beyond reality television and into our everyday lives. Whether we’re using a work laptop, downloading an app or walking through a public space with cameras, our behaviour can be influenced by the knowledge that somebody may be recording what we do.

Will Sayers in a suit
Dr Will Sayers

“There can be legitimate reasons for monitoring people, particularly where safety or security is concerned. Organisations may need to investigate wrongdoing, protect information or prevent crime, but that doesn’t mean collecting as much information as possible is always the right answer.”

Dr Sayers warns that increased monitoring can sometimes have unintended consequences, making people less willing to seek out information, raise concerns or report problems.

Dr Sayers said: “Researchers have long discussed what’s known as a ‘chilling effect’, where people change their behaviour because they believe they are being observed. In some cases, monitoring can even drive conversations onto unofficial channels that organisations are less able to protect or oversee, such as a personal email account.

“In 2013, a study by the University of Toronto found that visits to Wikipedia articles on sensitive topics such as ‘dirty bombs’ and ‘chemical weapon’ fell after revelations about US government surveillance of Wikipedia.

“While we cannot be certain why every reader stayed away, the findings support the concern that being watched can put people off seeking information they are perfectly entitled to read.”

Drawing a parallel with reality television editing in shows such as I’m A Celebrity, Dr Sayers said data should never be treated as a complete picture of events and that the context around them mattered.

Dr Sayers said: “One of the lessons from shows like I’m A Celebrity is that hours of footage can be edited into a short story that fits a particular narrative. Data works in much the same way.

“A record might show that somebody spent little time at their keyboard, but it can’t tell you whether they were idle, collaborating with colleagues or working through a complex problem.

“That’s why transparency, independent oversight and the ability to challenge decisions are so important. Whoever controls the camera, or the spreadsheet, shouldn’t automatically have the final say on what the story means.”